Archives for category: loss

A Sabbath Prayer for my father, who took his own life on April 20, 2015. And who is missed so very much…

Shabbat

Adonai were you with him as he drew his last breath?
His final exhale, releasing him of the pain & torment.
His soul cleansed and once again at peace.

It was not his time. But still I pray that you welcomed him into your care, to a place where he would hurt no more.

Tonight we kindle the lights of Shabbat.
He was lost in the darkness God. I pray that each day he is bathed in light. It is how I want to picture him, basking in the warmth of the sun. His favorite way to sit & pass the time.

Tonight we say the Kiddush and sip the wine.
He could not see or taste the sweetness that surrounded him God. It was in the kiss of his beloved bride. It was in the hearts of his children. It was in the love of his grandchildren. I pray that he knew that, that he still does. And I pray that the bitter taste of tears no longer lingers upon his lips. Rather, may there be a way he can still savor all that he was to us. It is we who cry now…

Tonight we bless the bread. The braided strands so symbolic of family. Each of us so deeply & intimately intertwined. And yet, there is a strand missing God.

Adonai my God, the Sabbath wish is for Shalom, for wholeness & peace. May he know it now God. He had not known it for so long. May you help us to know it once again. It seems so far from reach. We piece together the fragments each day, but the missing parts remain. How do we mend Adonai? Help us, guide us. Nurture in us the strength we need to rebuild. Tend to our spirits & our hearts so that they may know and truly feel joy once more.

And please God, place a kiss upon his cheek for us, tell him that we miss him, hold him in your everlasting embrace and once in a while, let him come to visit us. A whisper in the wind, a face in our dreams, or a rainbow in the sky.

Adonai, on this Sabbath eve. As the tears still fall. This is my most fervent prayer.

colorado

Okay, let’s start–kids are getting ready for camp, two leave next Wednesday, the other a week from Sunday. Movers arrive on the 17th. Change is coming. Change alone is overwhelming, under the best of circumstances, but change in the midst of grief also feels like another layer of loss is being added to the already complex aftermath of my father’s suicide. More goodbyes, my people, friends, community, support systems–just as I begin to get my sea legs back–wobbly & unsteady as they may be, the ground shifts and it feels at times like my knees might buckle. So I try and listen to what my body is telling me-and I honor my needs. I am blessed that my husband, partner and best friend is so willing to shoulder far more than his fair share of this transition, camp preparation and the million and one logistical pieces that need to be put into place… Goodbyes are hard, they feel even harder right now. The future is filled with excitement, yes I am happy and pleased that we’ve chosen this new adventure–but we didn’t know that the journey would be one that happened in the midst of grieving and healing. So I deep breath it, I small picture it, I talk about it, I write about it, I cry about it and I do my best to walk through it, baby step by baby step.

Change is coming. A leap of faith… it’s not easy to jump right now. I simply have to believe that there will be people to catch me on the other end–as I let go of the many hands that have held me up through this grief. Change is coming-it is full of promise… this I know. But it hurts to say goodbye–and as I throw myself into the great unknown, I carry with me the broken pieces… this I also know. But healing can happen anywhere, if we are surrounded by love….

The only way that we can live, is if we grow. The only way that we can grow is if we change. The only way that we can change is if we learn. The only way we can learn is if we are exposed. And the only way that we can become exposed is if we throw ourselves out into the open. Do it. Throw yourself.
― C. JoyBell C.

Dear Dad,

In my support group they say that it is important not to live with guilt, but rather to frame those feelings in regret. Guilt, they say, will become all consuming, regret is difficult, but in time it is easier to learn to live with. Makes sense…

So, I wanted to tell you a few things I regret.

I regret that we lost six precious years together due to our estrangement. I know we came out of it stronger, we did more than simply survive it. But I do wish it hadn’t taken us so long to find healing, wholeness & renewal. How many more precious memories might we have had?

I regret that I did not recognize the full depth of your suffering.

I regret any time I encouraged you to “fake it until you feel it.” How exhausting it must have been to try…

I regret that when you told me you truly felt depressed, that I didn’t ask you if you ever thought of harming yourself. It didn’t occur to me. You never said it.

I regret that in all of our talks, and there were so many, that I wasn’t able to give you more, to do more, to see more. I tried. I tried to listen, to be present, to validate all that you felt and to encourage you to get help, to keep talking, to continue treading water, rather than sink.

I regret that I did not get to say goodbye one final time.

I regret that I did not get to tell you I love you one final time.

I regret that I didn’t truly understand the signs. People ask often if there were any. The answer is yes, but without a full understanding of the symptoms of depression, without knowing that you were only sharing a part of your pain & suffering, without you ever uttering the words that would set off the alarms–I didn’t see them.

I’m sorry Dad. I regret that I couldn’t do more. I loved you as best as I could. I regret that it wasn’t enough to help save you.

And most of all–I regret that you and I will not have more time together.

Deborah

deb and dad baby

This post was originally posted to my Facebook page on 5/29/15.

Dear Dad,
It’s Shabbat. Soon we will light the candles. I cooked today, sweet & sour lentils. I even made a banana bread. I haven’t found the joy in cooking again. But I am doing a little more of it. Feeling good at least to be feeding my family good food, healthy food, food that nurtures their bodies. Cooking & baking truly fed my soul before that phone call, before you took your life, before we buried you. I know that feeling will come back, but for now-no photos of my food, no recipes shared on social media, nope, I’m not there yet. I miss you dad. The words to Mourner’s Kaddish do not come easily. Simply uttering them makes the loss seem somehow so much more real & palpable. You were never really a religious man dad. I wonder if you had been, if it might’ve been easier for you to have “faith” that things would get better. It’s another one of those questions dad, the kind you’ll never answer, the kind I’ll never really get to ask. There are so many of those damn questions. Where are you dad? That’s another one–why can’t you come and visit me in a dream? Whisper to me in the wind and tell me you’re okay? I always wonder that dad-Are you okay? It’s Shabbat. We kindle the lights, we bless the wine & the challah. We welcome the Sabbath Bride into our midst. We wish for shalom, peace, on Shabbat. I haven’t found it yet Daddy. But I’m trying… I love you. And I miss you more than words can say.
Love,
Deborah

ShabbatCandles-733683

deb and dad childhood 2

The criticism that hurts the most is the one that echoes my own self-condemnation. (Hugh Prather)

You condemned yourself–in your final months on earth, in word, in deed & ultimately in death. Was the criticism you inflicted upon yourself that powerful? More powerful than the love & blessings that surrounded you?

I wonder if you are at peace Dad.
Did you end your pain, leave your torment behind.
I wish that for you. I wish for you that you found solace, wholeness, shalom, when you returned your soul to God’s care.
I wish I knew…

But then I think, well that isn’t really fair now is it Dad?
What if you are at peace? That is great for you. But, if I’m honest, that kind of pisses me off. Because you took your life, ended YOUR pain, and you left the rest of us with a mess! We’re not at peace Dad. We are muddling through it, loving one another down this dark & difficult road. But we are going to have to work really hard to MAKE peace with your death. It doesn’t seem quite fair now does it dad? I mean, you were a numbers guy after all. Does this seem like a fair equation?

What a painful irony it is. To wish at once that you are at peace, and that you might be hurting, just a little, for what we, your family & friends, have to endure. To be profoundly sad that I don’t know if you are okay, and to be mad that even if you are–we are not! It’s like a ping-pong game of emotions. Some days it’s exhausting.

I want to know your pain is over. That with God, you are no longer suffering. And I want to know that you have regret, that your heart is breaking just a little at the pain of those you loved & who loved you.

I don’t know what I want Dad. I want you. I want to sit across from you and tell you exactly how I am feeling right now. I want to yell at you and hug you, admonish you and hear your voice. I want to tell you that I love you, and that I’m angry, and sad…

Shalom is peace, a sense of wholeness. I wish for it, for you, for our family, for me. But we would not have to seek wholeness, if we were not left to pick up the broken pieces. The pieces you left behind.

You were broken inside, your soul in such pain, coming apart bit by painful bit. Depression took hold and chipped away at you, leaving a fragment of the person you had been before.

Now you are with God. I pray that there you have found healing. I do Dad. You deserve that, even if you didn’t fight to find it here on Earth.

And I forgive you… most of the time. But I hope you shed a tear or two each time we weep, or struggle or search for you. Because I think that we deserve that too…

It’s not that we fear the place of darkness but that we don’t think we are worth the effort to find a place of light. (Hugh Prather)

Leora & her grandpa

Leora & her grandpa

Dear Dad,

Yesterday marked three weeks since we said our final goodbye at your funeral. I miss you. I miss your voice. Throughout my day there are those moments when it hits me, I will never see you again. I will never talk to you again. I will never get to hug you again, hear you laugh, see you smile. And when it hits me it is like a punch in the gut.

I started going to a support group dad. Survivors of Suicide, that is what we are called now. I shake my head in shock and disbelief simply at the words, at the very notion that we can call ourselves that. But we do.

When I sit in that room, surrounded by others who have lost a loved one to suicide, I find some comfort. The comfort of being among people who know, truly know, the loss, the pain, the struggle, the sadness and the shock of losing someone who mattered so deeply to them, to mental illness & suicide. It helps me to know that the things I am feeling, experiencing are “normal”, if one can truly call any of this “normal.” I suppose it is our “new normal.”

I cry a lot, I sit and listen, and I get to talk about what I am feeling with no guard up, no need to soften or hide the rawness of my grief. Most people don’t like to witness grief in it’s rawest form, it makes them uncomfortable. But there, among my fellow survivors, my grief can come out unfiltered.

Dad, I read a quote from Anderson Cooper that said, “That is the thing about suicide, try as you might to remember how a person lived his life, you always end up thinking about how he ended it.” I hope that’s not true Dad. I truly do. But, here’s the thing… right now, it is. It is the truth I confront daily and it’s hard dad, so very, very fucking hard.

I need to tell you something dad. The hardest piece for me in this last week, has been this…

Your last months on this earth were not happy ones. Yes, you had moments of happiness, but they did not linger. You were struggling, suffering. You died sad daddy. There was no last fantastic & happy hurrah for us to savor. It had been a long time since we’d seen you smile, since we heard joy or even contentment in your voice.

You died alone dad. I struggle with that so much. There was no one there to hold your hand. There was no one there to wipe your tears. There was no one there to tell you not to be afraid.

You died with no goodbyes. No final moments for us to tell you we love you.

That is the part that cuts me the deepest as the shock wears off dad. You were in emotional pain, you died alone, and we did not get to say goodbye.

And dad, here is one more of the most difficult truths I grapple with. I know your death was not a peaceful one.

So dad, I hope Anderson Cooper isn’t right. I hope in time, I’ll be able to think of you and reflect on happier times. I believe that if I travel through this grief openly & honestly, hard as it is (and it is fucking hard dad) I’ll find that in time, happier thoughts come to mind. That I’ll begin to smile through the tears, and even be able to smile without them when I think of the journey we shared, the lessons we learned, the hardships we endured, the battles we fought and above all…. the love we shared as father & daughter.

I miss you dad. I miss you so fucking much. And I hate the way you died… I just hate it.
You deserved so much more than that. We all did.
D

Yael  and her grandpa

Yael and her grandpa

dawn

Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul
And sings the tune without the words
And never stops at all.
― Emily Dickinson

Where did hope go in those early morning hours, before the dawn had come? I wonder.

When you were drowning in a sea of shame & sorrow? Where did hope go?

When you felt yourself blanketed in darkness & despair. Where did hope go?

When the worry shouted in your ear, playing a soundtrack with no end. Where did hope go?

When your mind thundered with pain, a pain so vast it echoed into your soul. Where did hope go?

When sadness settled in, like a thick & heavy fog. Where did hope go?

When you allowed yourself to believe that we would be better off without you. Where did hope go?

When you reached not for the loving hands that had held yours for 55 years, grasping on for dear life-but instead turned towards death, ending your pain once and for all. Where did hope go?

I know what it means to be hopeful. Hope-full. Full of hope…

Some will tell me you were hopeless. Hope-less. Less hope. But isn’t less hope still hope? Doesn’t that mean there is still some hope present? It is not yet fully gone or depleted? It is less, but it is not none.

Where was hope in those early morning hours? My head tells me that hope had been present throughout, but it was barricaded tightly behind the doors of mental illness, pounding, fighting, trying desperately to reach you, to stop you. Hope held in one hand a mirror, seeking to hold it to your face, to make you see that even in your broken state, you were loved, you were needed, you had value, you were enough. And in the other hand, hope held a compass. A way to guide you forward, day by day, inch by inch, breath by blessed breath until you found balance & peace once again.

That is what my mind tells me. But my heart feels simply this:

In those early morning hours when the lure of death showed you a world where you would not hurt anymore, when you had lost hope and no longer had the strength & clarity to find it once again-it feels simply like…

For you…
Hope-Left

And that hurts my heart most of all…. because had you held on daddy, you’d have come to see–that hope lost, can always be found again. And it’s absence is only fleeting….

Where was hope on that early morning, April 20, 2015? It was there daddy–but you were too immersed in darkness to see it…

Hope is faith holding out its hand in the dark. ~George Iles

hope

outside-flower-arrangements

A flower’s appeal is in its contradictions — so delicate in form yet strong in fragrance, so small in size yet big in beauty, so short in life yet long on effect. ~Terri Guillemets

My father loved spring. The world would come to life. Sitting outside, basking in the returning warmth of the sun, he would take in the blossoming of the trees, the budding of the flowers.

When the world looked cold & barren, on those winter days in New York, he discovered a way to add color to the backdrop of such bleakness.

In a wealth of clay pots, he planted silk flowers. Placing them along the walkway, sitting them out on the deck. He could lift the shades, as he did first thing every morning, and there they would be. No matter the season, they were full of color, if not full of life.

Silk flowers never die. The elements can not uproot them. When life’s passing storms hit, their color remains vibrant. They do not need the warmth of sun to nurture them, the buzzing of the bees to help the garden grow. Mother Nature can shower them with harsh rains, it will not hurt them. She can unleash wintry snows, their beauty stands bold against the winter white. She can coat them in a blanket of darkness, they will not wither. And when the earth is parched, longing for rain, they will not starve.

But they are not real. No, the most beautiful of flowers is a precious symbol of life. When darkness falls upon them, robbing them of light, they wither. When they sit in the center of the storm, they bend, they break. When their roots search in vain for sustenance, they are parched, weakened, so very fragile.

We are like precious flowers. And we are subject to the seasons & storms of life. When we feel immersed in the darkness, unable to bend toward the light, we wither. When it feels as if our roots are unsteady, no longer grounded, we lose our strength. When each day seems to bring a new storm, our colors become dim, less vibrant. And when it feels as if the storms will never pass, bit by bit, it is as if a piece of us feels it is dying. Even if it is not.

How I wish my father was a silk flower. But he was not. His life was a precious one. He had weathered many storms, and he had basked in the sunlight. He put down roots, and planted a garden & he tended it. At times it was full of life, and other seasons saw it struggle. But it was his garden. He was not a perfect flower, flawed as we all are. The petals told a story, his story, our story.

Life gave him too many dark days these last months. He couldn’t find the sunlight. He couldn’t feel the strength of his roots. He could not trust that though he might bend in the storm, he need not break. He couldn’t trust that the garden he had nurtured, would not let him wither, that he was not casting a shadow over our own bright rays of sun.

But we who loved him know, he could have once again blossomed. Like a flower in the spring, he could once again stand tall. His roots that much stronger because of all he had endured. The sun would shine again, and soon the storms of winter would have been in the past. He could have once again felt joy, as he looked at the garden that surrounded him. There would be a return of the vibrant hues that had filled his life before. Beauty would replace pain…

My father loved silk flowers. But silk flowers are not real. And they can only endure life’s storms, because they can not feel them.

When the night has been too lonely
And the road has been too long
And you think that love is only
For the lucky and the strong
Just remember in the winter
Far beneath the bitter snows
Lies the seed that with the sun’s love
In the spring becomes the rose (The Rose by Bette Midler)

roses-in-winter

greene party1652

I’ve written many Facebook Posts since Losing my father, Lowell Jay Herman, on April 20, 2015.

Here I share them once again, reflecting on each one as I live our loss out loud.

My Father’s Death (written 4/20/15)
Early this morning, my father lost his battle with mental illness. My heart is broken. May his memory be for an eternal & abiding blessing… and may he know how grateful I was for the gifts of reconciliation & healing–I got these last few years with my father, and that is a gift I will forever be grateful for. I will miss him more than words can say… I only wish I could tell him how much he meant to me, one last time. To hear his voice, to say I love you–and if only I had another chance to remind him-that it would get better, to hang on to hope even if only by his fingertips–but instead, I travel with my family to New York, to say goodbye to a beloved father, father-in-law, grandfather, friend, brother and husband–and to return his soul to God. I love you daddy!

He is Gone (4/20/15)
My beloved father Lowell Jay Herman. I want just one more moment–one more hug-one more I love you–I want to wake up from this horrific nightmare and know that you are still here–that the despair you were feeling, the depression–did not truly take you from us–but I will not get that. My heart and soul ache with a sadness I can not even put into words–Depression robbed our family of so many years–so many joyous moments yet to be, so many more opportunities to say I love you–and I feel as if I am stuck in quicksand–barely able to breathe, to think, to process. My father, my friend–how can it be that you are gone? I will cherish and miss this smile for the rest of my days. I only wish your last moments on this earth were not filled with so much pain–I love you daddy–always! I hope your soul is finally at peace..

The Funeral (4/23/15)
Today I lay my father to rest. My heart is broken. Beloved husband, father, grandfather, family man and friend. And as we grapple to come to terms with how he died, today we honor how he lived, what he meant to us and the legacy he leaves behind. I don’t know how to travel through this grief, but today, surrounded by family, supported by friends and enveloped in prayer, I will say goodbye to my dad one final time. And then I face a world without him.

Shiva (4/24/15)
Each morning I wake, there are those few moments when it doesn’t seem real. I sit in the house I grew up in, the house where my mother and father lived, but my father isn’t here. Yes, he is here in spirit, still very much a presence, but his physical being is no longer going to walk through those doors, sit at this table or bask in the sun out on the front porch. I keep thinking I missed something, a sign that perhaps, had I seen it, could’ve helped to save him. We who are left behind, grapple with the questions, trying desperately to understand this tragic loss. How do you explain the unexplainable? The answers we seek will never come, but perhaps it is simply in the talking, the sharing of our truth, that we can help to lift the shroud of shame and secrecy that surround mental illness and encourage a dialogue that might one day, save the life of another person struggling with depression. The Talmud says, “whoever saves a life, it is considered as if he saved an entire world.” I couldn’t save my father, but in his memory, and in his honor and in sharing his story, perhaps I can, in some small way, help to save another.

Leaving New York (4/26/15)
So very hard to leave my family in NY. Who else knew and loved my father in the same way and carries the same grief. Grateful for the time we had to hold one another and simply be together. And, despite the void we feel, to laugh and smile as we reminisced of happier times. And as the resilient spirits of our children lifted our spirits, basking in their laughter. And now, I return home to sit shiva amongst our community in Atlanta, and then to slowly make the journey back to life once again. I am profoundly grateful to the friends of old who gave of their presence while we were here, those who remember my dad as a young man full of life and spirit, and who share memories with me no one else ever will. And it comforts me to know my mother, my brother and his family are surrounded by so much love and support. Now it is to our community we return, secure in the knowledge that loving arms and hearts full of compassion and sympathy await.

Suicide & Mental Health-Sharing Painful Lessons (4/27)
One week ago, I received the devastating and heartbreaking phone call from my brother. My father had taken his own life. And as we stumble through this enormous and overwhelming pain, we will not hide from that truth. Suicide is not an act of cowardice, it is an act of pain. But to save a life, we must be open and honest about mental illness. We must not let shame relegate those who suffer, and their loved ones, to the shadows. Today, I learned that in 2013, someone died every 12.8 seconds by suicide. My precious father was not and is not a statistic, but sadly in some way, I must include him among these numbers. But it will not end there, through my tears, and my anguish, I will share his loss, and his life, openly and honestly. I will share his joy and his pain, his hope and his fears and the battle with the disease, yes, the illness, that took him from us far too soon. Because that is the only way I know to make sense of the senseless, and to honor my beloved father. One week ago, I received the devastating phone call. Perhaps if we are honest and open, another family might be spared that pain.

Shiva Ends (4/29/15)
Tonight, the torn black ribbon comes off, no longer to serve as a daily reminder of loss & mourning. The period of shiva ends, and slowly we must all begin to find our way back to life, to joy & to fond remembrance. But we do so with a void, and we do so continuing to grapple with the aftermath of the way in which my father’s life ended. The questions do not adhere to a timeline, the search for missed signs, or the things we would’ve, could’ve or should’ve done, must play themselves out. I think it’s only natural, at least that is what I’ve come to understand as I read about suicide, a topic I never thought I’d need or have to become knowledgeable about. I pray in time, with healing, and with understanding, and with a gentle loving of ourselves, those questions will no longer be the soundtrack that plays when we think of my dad, that the smiles and happy memories will find their way to the forefront, though in truth, they will always be accompanied in some way by his loss. In time, the tears won’t flow so freely, and the pain of picking up the phone to say hello to my dad, only to realize that I can’t, that I never will again, won’t hurt quite as much. Today, shiva ends, the ribbon comes off, my heart is still broken, so perhaps simply putting one foot in front of the other, breathing in the promise of each new day and being kind to myself & allowing myself to feel what I need to feel-is all I can really ask right now…

Sitting on the Front Porch Swing (5/3/15)
As I sit out here, on our front porch swing, my fathers favorite place to sit when he came to visit, I’m looking at the sign that sits on our front lawn. “Sale Pending” it says. The day we went under contract I called my parents to share the good news. It was the last time I would speak to my father, and the last piece of good news I will ever get to share with him. My dad sent me a text on Sunday morning. It read, “Great to hear it all went so well. Love you.” That was Sunday, and on Monday he was gone. So as I sit out here swinging, smiling as I think of him, tears fill my eyes. Time is so very precious and it is fleeting. For 6 years my family and I were estranged. When I wrote to my parents, to try and heal the rift, I told Fred Greene, I simply could not bear the thought of my parents leaving this earth without knowing, I loved them, I forgave them, I was sorry for the ways that I had hurt them and that should they be open to it, I stood ready and willing to heal, to love and to bring wholeness back into our lives. My father said that when they received that first letter, on Rosh Hashanah, he told my mother that “it was truly a blessed day.” Reconciliation is a gift. My father did not leave this earth without knowing I loved him. And my family and I shared 3 more precious years together. We loved each other for the flawed and imperfect beings we are. That is the most authentic love there is. And so, swinging on this porch, gazing at this sign, tears rolling gently down my face, smiling through the tears, my message is simple, love honestly, forgive, heal where you can, and shed the burden of anger and hurt. I got to share one final piece of good news with my dad, a final I love you… Time is fleeting and oh so precious and forgiveness is a gift.

Grief (5/4/15)
Grief is a process, a journey. We cannot rush through it, nor can we flip a switch and simply turn it off. Two weeks ago I lost my father to suicide. Yes, I know there will come a day when I can more readily think about the life he lived, rather than the way he died. There will come a day when the pain of his death does not feel like a weight upon my heart, but rather a dull ache that lives alongside of his memory. A day when I will smile, more than I cry when I think of him. But to grieve is to feel, to grapple and to hurt. Tomorrow I am going to a support group for Survivors of Suicide. Yes we, the loved ones left behind, have a name, an identity, membership in a club no one would ever choose to belong to. And yet, the loss we grieve has initiated us. Grief is a process, we all travel through it in our own way, but I believe that to travel it openly and honestly, honoring our emotions, our struggles and our feelings, is how we ultimately return ourselves to a place of healing and wholeness. Two weeks ago, just two, I lost my father to suicide, and I am profoundly sad, I grapple for answers that will never come, I struggle daily with how he died. I put one foot in front of the other, I breathe, I share & I talk. I busy myself with life, I seek strength and comfort in the company of family and friends. I eat the meals cooked and delivered so lovingly by others… and yes, I grieve, I hurt, I cry and I miss my dad.

Painful Realities (5/6/15)
A visit to the doctor today. We need to review your history the nurse says. Medicine list comes first, then medical history. On we move to family history. You have 3 children at home? Yes. Daughters? Yes. You have one brother? Yes. And you still have your mother and your father? The tears fill my eyes, before I can stop them. No, my father just passed away 2 weeks ago. What was the cause? With a heart full of pain, I take a deep breath, then answer…suicide. She offers heartfelt condolences & I can see she is sincere. And then she returns to the computer and the change is entered into my records. I watch her use the mouse and where once the box was checked yes next to father, it is no longer. Instead, the check finds a new permanent position filling up the box which says no. And a notation is made about cause of death. The records now reflect the painful truth, my father is no longer with me. He took his own life. A routine visit to the doctor, a review of medical & personal history. An already raw & open wound now fills with waves of pain. It was a routine visit to the doctor, but I left feeling as if I’d been punched in the gut. And wishing there was medicine for the ache in my soul.

Thank you (5/9/15)
What do you say to a man who loves you through such a tragic and horrific loss? Who honors your grief, your need to mourn, your profound sense of sadness and your pain at losing a father to suicide? Who gives your father one final gift and honors your mother, by eulogizing and burying your dad with such love, respect and dignity? Who shares from the pulpit our need to end the stigma and shame surrounding mental illness and suicide, even as he does so with a lump in his throat and tears in his eyes? Who silently holds your hand, wipes your tears and offers his presence not platitudes? And who seeks daily to lighten your burden of tasks and chores so you can focus on taking care of yourself? Thank you seems too small a word. It can’t possibly encompass your gratitude? Surely there must be something more grandiose to say, but I’ve not yet found it. My father would likely know, grabbing his scrabble dictionary and offering up some obscure word that I might use. And I know that from his place with God, he’d let me know if he could, because I know he too is grateful to have been laid to rest by such loving hands. So I’ll rely on these two little words for my husband Fred Greene thank you my love…. My kind, sweet and compassionate husband and friend. I don’t think I could navigate this dark and difficult path without you by my side. “I would thank you from the bottom of my heart, but my heart has no bottom” (author unknown)


Picture of me 1

deb and dad

Grief is not a disorder, a disease or a sign of weakness. It is an emotional, physical and spiritual necessity, the price you pay for love. The only cure for grief is to grieve. – Rabbi Earl Grollman

How are you? Three little words. Sometimes we ask them in passing, not even waiting for an answer. At other times we ask in a more perfunctory way. And then there are the times we ask in a way that says, “Tell me your truth. I really want to know.”

In recent months, each time I would speak to my dad, I would ask him, “How are you dad?” But I always followed those three words with this, “Dad, I’m asking because I really want to know, so answer me honestly. How are you?” My father would often sigh, take a deep breath and answer, “I’m not doing so good.” And then we would talk. Sometimes we talked for a very long time, other times the conversations were shorter. But each time, I would offer my dad my presence, I would listen, and I would share with him. I did not offer him platitudes, there was no purpose in them. He was in real pain, and he needed to have that pain acknowledged, to share his burden and to feel safe that his struggles would be met with care, with respect and with love. I’d like to believe that I was able to do that for him. That he carried with him the knowledge that I did not take lightly the darkness he felt surrounded him and the fears & worries that kept him up at night and clouded his days.

And now, here I am. It is just a little over two weeks since my father committed suicide. I am profoundly sad, and I am struggling with the very real & painful aftermath of how my father died.

People ask me, “How are you?” Some ask in passing, the obligatory words to the mourner. Some don’t bother asking at all. Their silence is deafening. Some ask & then, with the best of intentions, offer platitudes. “Don’t think about how your father died. Think only about the life he lived & the good times.” “You have to know that your father’s suicide had nothing at all to do with your family.” “You have to be strong for your mother, for your children.” And others ask, with hearts ready to receive my grief, my hurt and my sadness.

Here is the thing I’ve learned. So many people are uncomfortable with grief. They want to pretty it up, make you feel better and offer you a better and more hopeful way to look at your loss. It comes from a good place, at least most of the time. People who care about you, want to see you happy, smiling, embracing life. But, grief is a journey, it is a process. And the grief around suicide adds a painful, complex and heart-wrenching layer that, if you’ve not lived it (and I hope you never do) is truly beyond the realm of understanding.

I get up every day. I put one foot in front of the other. I busy myself with life, errands, things around the house. I take care of my children, go to appointments, prepare for our upcoming move. I eat, I go for a walk. And I grieve. And I grapple. And I miss my father. And I regret that I couldn’t do more to help him, that I didn’t see just how deep his pain went. I cry, I talk, I reflect. I reach out to support systems so that I can be around people who understand this particular kind of loss. And I simply allow myself to feel.

Grief isn’t easy. It isn’t pretty. It can’t be wished away. And no matter how hard we may try to bury it, it will find a way in. Grief is a journey, we simply must walk through it. The grief surrounding suicide does not come with a compass, there is no road map, and it can feel so very isolating and confusing. So each step forward feels more uncertain, unsure and at times, unsettling. But I walk, I breathe & I cry. I may stop and sit, perhaps to reflect, or perhaps because I feel so very tired. Sadness will leave you feeling that way.

But I believe in my heart that the only way to healing, is to journey through the grief. I do not do it on a timetable. I can’t. I won’t. I loved my father. I lost my father. My father committed suicide. And I am grieving.

So, if you ask me those three words, “How are you?” Ask with the intention of knowing, of listening, of simply being present. Ask knowing you have no answers, and that is okay. Ask with a willingness to simply sit in silence with me, or allow me to cry in your company. Ask in a way that honors my grief. And in that way, you help me to honor my father. Ask with the intention of truly knowing, or please… simply don’t ask at all.

How are you? Three little words. It is in the asking, that you can make all the difference to someone who is learning to live with such a deep & profound loss.

We can endure much more than we think we can; all human experience testifies to that. All we need to do is learn not to be afraid of pain. Grit your teeth and let it hurt. Don’t deny it, don’t be overwhelmed by it. It will not last forever. One day, the pain will be gone and you will still be there. – Rabbi Harold Kushner